hey broken, youre right on both accounts its not likely people will chuck shells at each other while driving or fire fireballs in a brawl; and djing is reasonably accessible. but so are skateboarding, or playing bball yet i loved tony hawk when it first came back donkeys ago and nba2k looks like it rocks. i personally would prefer to play on my turntables rather then play dj hero, while i cant be assed to learn to skate, yet love skateboard flicks and hence enjoy the game. theres prob a group of people who say skate and love music, but would never go the path of djing. its definitely not for all gamers, but there is no one game to suit all (except maybe zelda.. ha ha) maybe people are hating because the controls are so close to home in terms of looking like decks. if it was a simple colour tap tap game using the regular controller, but with the same blend style of music, it probably wouldnt get as much grief. oh well, if it even just gets a handful of people onto the likes of z-trip and shadow, even AM, then its done some good. ps ya reckon on the aus assasins forum their having the same debate about tomorrows release